Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Try Hard 
 Strangled Soward was hard done by 

Strangled Soward was hard done by

The wash-up from Jamie Soward's tackle on Greg Inglis has me scratching my head.

First up, I don't understand why the onfield officials, at the direction of video ref Bill Harrigan, awarded an eight-point try.

I'd always thought an eight-point try was for fouls committed in the act of scoring. By my reckoning, Inglis was a good few metres shy of the tryline when the incident happened. So how is that in the act of scoring? Surely he has to at least be over the tryline - otherwise every penalty awarded within a metre of the line should be an eight-point try.

  • Read more Try Hard blogs

  • Full coverage of The St George Illawarra Dragons

    Second ly, I don't get how Soward was cited and Inglis wasn't. The replays are crystal clear - Inglis isn't fending off Soward, he has his right hand around his throat, strangling him "like a chicken" as coach Wayne Bennett would later say.

    I simply cannot work out how any player - attacker or defender - has the right to wrap a hand around an opponent's neck. Doing that while a player is moving, as Soward was, is an action that could cause a player serious injury.

    And yet Inglis walks away scot-free.

    The thing I really don't get is the issue of the grading. The league's match review committee chairman Greg McCallum said it would have been greater than the grade one Soward got had he injured Inglis.

    "There was contact with his (Soward's) leg to Inglis's face and obviously any injury or additional force could have led to a higher grading," McCallum said.

    Now cast your mind back a few weeks to the third State of Origin, where Jonathan Thurston kicked David Williams in the face after he'd scored.

    That broke Williams' cheekbone. So, by the match review chairman's own definition, Thurston's inflicting an injury should have seen him get a high grading.

    Yet Thurston scored just a grade one - same as Soward. So the Dragons playmaker, whose leg barely brushed Inglis' face, gets the same penalty as Thurston, who kicked a player full-on in the face.

    They're not even close to being the same offence.

    If Thurston's was a grade one, then Soward's was a grade minus-10.

  • Print
    Increase Text Size
    Decrease Text Size

    comments


    Date: Newest first | Oldest first
    The reason why Jamie Soward was charged was because it was GREG INGLIS the hero of the nation. Greg Inglis gets away with everything.The media fall all over themselves every time he plays I am sick to death of it. I hope Melbourne get beaten the first week.
    Posted by sammy, 7/08/2009 9:58:09 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
    Sammy,

    I don't want Melbourne to get beaten in the first week of the finals.

    I want them to get flogged.


    Posted by Glen Humphries on 7/08/2009 12:07:08 PM
    What are you guys talking about? Everyone knows the NRL has it in for Melbourne and always has.

    Listening to the Melbourne fans sitting around me last Friday night at WIN Jubi, it was clear that Soward should have been rubbed out for the season, I tells ya!

    Posted by Efresh, 7/08/2009 8:27:58 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    Try Hard
    Glen Humphries has been a Dragons fan since 1976 and admits he has spent a fair bit of the off-season watching his copy of the 2010 grand final DVD.
    Picture: ANDY ZAKELI
    Picture: ANDY ZAKELI
    Related Coverage
    BLOGS
    05 August, 2009
    04 August, 2009
    29 July, 2009
    27 July, 2009
    22 July, 2009

    Most popular articles




    Illawarra Mercury







    Weather brought to you by:

    Weatherzone

    Classifieds

    Front Page

    Current Issue
    Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
     SEND...
     SAVE...
     SHARE...