News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Doctor slams use of bottled water in hospital 

Doctor slams use of bottled water in hospital

15 Jul, 2009 10:45 AM
Wollongong Hospital is pouring money down the drain by providing bottled water to patients, a Wollongong doctor claims.

Patients receive a bottle of water with breakfast each morning and, rather than being asked to refill the bottles, new ones are available throughout their stay.

Visiting physician Dr Chris Dunn said the policy was damaging to the environment and a waste of hospital funding.

  • Is providing bottled water to patients a waste of money? Join the debate and post a comment below.

    "It would appear to me it would be quite costly rather than getting (water) out of a tap," Dr Dunn said.

    "I have not yet been able to work out the reason for such extravagance with funds and resources."

    A South Eastern Sydney Illawarra Health spokesperson said bottled water use at the hospital was based on ease of handling and patients' clinical needs.

    "Bottled water is purchased very economically under the government contract," the spokesperson said. "Normal recycling systems are in place to minimise the impact on the environment."

    Other hospitals in the South Eastern Sydney Illawarra Health area provide jugs and cups or use the Visy Closed Loop recycling system.

    Dr Dunn said he could not understand why bottled water was introduced to Wollongong Hospital several months ago.

    "I don't think it would be because of bugs around the place," he said, " because all the jugs would normally be washed and sterilised.

    " I can't see that a jug on a locker would be any different to having a bottle of water that's been opened and half drunk and left on the patient's locker."

    Dr Dunn said he hoped Premier Nathan Rees would include the hospital in his proposed ban of bottled water in government departments.

    Mr Rees announced last week he wanted all government services not to renew their bottled water contracts, after the Southern Highlands town of Bundanoon became the first in Australia, and probably the world, to ban bottled water.

  • Print
    Increase Text Size
    Decrease Text Size

    RELATED COVERAGE

    comments


    Date: Newest first | Oldest first
    Tap water is just as good, bottled stuff is a waste of money. I was in hospital recently & was provided with a cup of tea & instead of sugar there was a a low calory chemical alternative (not Equal or Sugarine). I don't care how many rats or monkeys survived clinical trials surely normal sugar isn't that bad.
    Posted by Leroy, 15/07/2009 11:31:48 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
    The only good reason is hygiene, as at some stage bottle would have to be washed. I can almost see the nightmare of returning the same bottle to patient that used it. Possibly water lady could go around and refill bottles but how to clean them properly on the spot? And how to avoid possible cross contamination while refilling? I think Hospital has legitimate reason to be little bit wasteful here, almost the same reason as single use syringe. Lets not forget about multi drug resistant bacteria in most of East Coast Hospitals.
    Posted by Barry, 15/07/2009 12:14:11 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    Bottled water has been supplied at Wollongong Hospital for over 2years Whether it is all wards I dont know, but those I have visited had bottled water.Maybe it's a labour saving exercise, as it is time consuming washing all those water jugs and mugs
    Posted by Annie, 15/07/2009 12:15:05 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    It is expensive convenience, but so is any type of recycling. Are the bottles properly recycled?
    Posted by Fergie, 15/07/2009 2:19:48 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    I agree with Barry. Bottled water sounds like a great hygenic idea. As Annie stated it may also be a labour saving idea. If it is inexpensive and recycled where is the problem?
    Posted by Real1st, 15/07/2009 4:26:52 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    Cant see that bottled water as being a plus for patients, as for concerns about health and hygiene...Stop Patients Smoking.
    Posted by Fish, 15/07/2009 4:27:04 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    I work in a hosptital catering department and it is actually cheaper to provide bottled water as it reduces wage costs..... If we cut costs we have more money to spend on the patients
    Posted by damain, 20/08/2009 2:17:00 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    How about doctors in hospitals giving better medical treatment instead of worrying about water.
    Posted by disgusted, 19/02/2011 2:23:12 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    If I was at hopital, for the price of a few bottles, I am sure that I would prefer not to risk contamination from other patient's "jugs" that escaped sterilisation. Lets remember that people go to hospital in times of sickness and the last thing needed is further complications to an already compromised immune system..

    I suggest that the patient be given the options more so than the making it a politician's popularity decision.


    Posted by LU, 27/06/2011 2:14:25 PM, on Illawarra Mercury

    post a comment


    Screen name  *
    Email address  *
    Remember me?
    Comment  *
     
    We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
    Related Coverage
    ARTICLES
    POLL
    Q: Should bottled water be banned for environmental reasons?

    YES
    (62.6%)

    NO
    (37.4%)

    Total Votes: 329
    Poll Date: 08 July, 2009

    Most popular articles


    Cool Blue Air Conditioning Pty Ltd
     


    Illawarra Mercury







    Weather brought to you by:

    Weatherzone

    Classifieds

    Front Page

    Current Issue
    Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
     SEND...
     SAVE...
     SHARE...