News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Heritage may prevent Port Kembla stack from coming down 

Heritage may prevent Port Kembla stack from coming down

29 Aug, 2009 04:00 AM
Plans to demolish the Port Kembla Copper stack could be derailed by an eleventh-hour Wollongong City Council suggestion that the 198m-high chimney has "heritage significance".

An environmental assessment, detailing the plans to use controlled explosions to bring down the stack, was placed on public display on April 30.

At the time Port Kembla Copper (PKC), which owns the site, told the Mercury it could cost up to $20 million to repair and preserve the stack and raised questions about who would be responsible for upkeep and safety into the future.

But PKC has now been told by the Department of Planning that it needs to submit a detailed heritage impact assessment before the demolition application can be determined.

Two other heritage listed items on the site - the Assay office building and a smaller brick chimney stack - are being retained.

It is understood that a full heritage assessment by PKC could cost up to $100,000 and delay the approval process by up to three months.

In a council submission to the Department of Planning, released to the Mercury by the council, general manager David Farmer said the demolition proposal should "not be approved" until a heritage assessment was completed.

"Whilst not a listed heritage item, it is clear that the 200m high stack proposed for demolition is of heritage significance," Mr Farmer wrote.

"The stack has become a grand and highly visible and evocative symbol of the importance of the industry of Port Kembla to the development of Wollongong and the Illawarra."

The submission also suggests the "archaeological potential" of the site and risk of disturbing relics has not been considered.

The close proximity of the site to heritage listed buildings on the former Port Kembla Public School site is also raised.

The council declined to comment on the submission as the Department of Planning was still assessing the application.

However, the Mercury understands the heritage of the stack has not previously been investigated and in July, the council resolved to undertake a major review of the city's outdated heritage schedule.

A Department of Planning spokesperson confirmed that Wollongong City Council and the NSW Heritage Branch had raised the heritage issue, prompting the request for further details from PKC.

"Potential impacts on the site's industrial heritage were one of the key issues raised in submissions received for the Port Kembla Copper demolition project," the spokesperson said.

"The department has requested that the proponent update their response to submissions to address these concerns."

Yesterday afternoon, PKC director Ian Wilson declined to comment on the council's heritage submission.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
i think it should have koori art work on it and made in to a big digeridoo
Posted by leave it alone, 29/08/2009 6:46:22 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Save the stack!
Posted by rose, 29/08/2009 7:36:45 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Save the stack!! It will probably cost more to have it removed than it would to maintain it for decades. No one wanted it gone when my mates and I were going to school under it at PKPS. At least we could SEE what we were breathing!! The mighty Blacks won many a match of the day at W/Gong showground running home towards the stack in the second half!!!!!! (lost a few too)!
Posted by FTW, 29/08/2009 8:01:46 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
What a farce - and an expensive one at that. A concrete chimney that no-one cared about when it was operational, but David Farmer and the council wants is treated as some sort of wonder of the world - it's not the pyramids fellas it's just a bloody chimney stack.

Let the company knock it down! If not, guess who will end up paying for this nonsense - the ratepayers!

And for those saying it could be put to use for tourism - if it's heritage listed no-one will be allowed to do anything with it and it will just stand there until it falls down.

Posted by Truestory, 29/08/2009 9:50:09 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Heritage value? Archaelogical site?....that's just ridiculous, its not Stonehenge, its a concrete cancer ridden eyesore. Not everything old needs to be preserved for posterity.
Posted by Jim, 29/08/2009 1:06:51 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
Good, because it's heritage and Port Kembla would not be the same without it. If you want to live in an industrial suburb you have to put up with the consequences.
Posted by Markm, 29/08/2009 2:49:17 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
I hope the Stack remains standing, it is a major part of Port Kembla history. I even remember the days when it was known as the ER&S stack. it would be a sad day indeed if it is to be brought down., because it would also certainly change the panoramic view and then Wollongong would look no different to any other city.
Posted by Freckles, 29/08/2009 3:16:56 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
I agree Don't knock it down it will be 1 of the saddest days ever if they did...
Posted by kelly at port, 30/08/2009 12:11:59 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
What a great asset to promote our region. I can see the tag line. "Drive the Sea Cliff Bridge and see the Stack - "Illawarra's Centre Point Tower" - Enjoy". That will bring them. The dollars will be rolling in. Charge them $15 each to watch a video "The History of the Stack", buy a "Stack" t-shirt and have a "Stack" ice cream. Better still we can sell the naming rights, the "ANZ Stack" or "Telstra Stack". Its visionary. Ridiculous I hear you say, then why is it being considered to retain something that is a blight on the landscape? Why is it that small insignficant minority groups always have the sway of Council? While I agree that in certain circumstances some heritage structures should be preserved and retained this is not one of them, it provides no community benefit. Who will maintain such a structure (Council?), or will it be left to decay, just like the North Wollongong Pavilion. MR
Posted by MR, 30/08/2009 11:33:39 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
1. This item is NOT heritage listed.

2. If Wollongong Council wanted to heritage list it they have had 30 years to do so.

3. It is an appalling abuse to require any property owner to spend $100,000 'proving' the non-heritage listed property is not a heritage item.

Posted by Smithy, 30/08/2009 12:17:47 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Picture: KIRK GILMOUR
Picture: KIRK GILMOUR
Related Coverage
POLL
Q: Should the Port Kembla Copper stack be demolished?

Yes
(52.8%)

No
(47.2%)

Total Votes: 566
Poll Date: 28 August, 2009

Most popular articles




Illawarra Mercury







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...