News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Noreen Hay snubs God Save The Queen 

Noreen Hay snubs God Save The Queen

01 Jul, 2009 05:37 PM
Well may we say God Save the Queen, but can he save Noreen?

That's the question Wollongong MP Noreen Hay may be asking this morning after she came under attack for not singing the former anthem at an official Anzac Day ceremony this year.

It may be the first time a politician has been criticised for not opening their mouth.

  • POLL: Should Noreen Hay apologise for not singing?

    Ms Hay has expressed regret for the hurt caused by her failure to sing at the ceremony, which upset the Wollongong War Widows' Guild so much they are considering objecting to her attendance next year.

    Guild president Audrey Laidlaw wrote to Ms Hay on May 1 on behalf of the branch's 60 members after several widows and servicemen complained that the MP remained silent during the Royal National Anthem (God Save the Queen), which was played as well as Advance Australia Fair at the town hall event.

    VIDEO: Sing along to God Save the Queen. This video includes lyrics

    Mrs Laidlaw this week said Ms Hay had not responded to the letter, which had needed approval from the War Widows' Guild of NSW before it was sent.

    But Ms Hay said she had replied in writing and was unsure why the response still hadn't been received.

    Because Ms Hay was a special guest at the ceremony, the reaction among older members at the town hall had been one of "upset, indignation and incense", Mrs Laidlaw said.

    "She was standing there in front of me and, unlike the people around her, she didn't open her mouth.

  • "If I didn't have all the people come up to me and complain I probably wouldn't have done anything.

    "But men went to World War I under that anthem and our husbands did in World War II as well - us war widows thought that it was disrespectful."

    Ms Hay, who was born in London, told the Mercury the last thing she had wanted to do was offend anyone.

    She said that on Anzac Day she had attended a dawn service at Port Kembla, visited veterans at City Diggers and then met her husband, children and grandchildren to "cheer and applaud the marchers".

    "My intention on the day was to pay my respects and honour the fallen, their families and their descendants," Ms Hay said.

    "The war widows have suggested that I have offended them by not singing God Save the Queen - this was never my intention and I extend my sincere regrets if that is the case."

    Ms Hay said she had written a reply to the letter from the guild and would investigate what had happened to it.

    She said she could not remember if she had sung at the town hall.

    Mrs Laidlaw said in her experience special guests sang both anthems at the services.

    It is the responsibility of the Anzac Day committee to invite special guests - including Ms Hay - to the ceremony next year.

    "But if it were up to me, I would say no," Mrs Laidlaw said.

    Print
    Increase Text Size
    Decrease Text Size
    Page:
    1

    comments


    Date: Newest first | Oldest first
    And this is news. Just being in attendance should be enough.
    Posted by onge, 1/07/2009 7:49:19 AM
    Obviously the organisers forgot to give her a sheet with the words on it
    Posted by Johne, 1/07/2009 9:11:38 AM
    Our National Anthem is Advance Australia Fair (whatever we may think of it), God Save the Queen is not. Anyway the Anthem at the time would have been God Save the King so those singing the contemporary version are incorrect.
    Posted by wife of vietnam veteran, 1/07/2009 9:46:44 AM
    It's the British anthem, times have moved on & there are many instances where Australia's best interests weren't served under British command.
    Posted by Leroy, 1/07/2009 10:22:16 AM
    "It may be the first time a politician has been criticised for not opening their mouth." I thought GSTQ had been replace by Advance Aust Fair in Australia. Or perhaps its republicanism personified - like PaulKeating who no only manhandled the Queen but instructed his then wife Anite not to curtesy. When in Rome, I think it is courteous to do as Rome does.
    Posted by Fergie, 1/07/2009 10:26:40 AM
    Get a life people!!! Why aren't we required to sing the New Zealand National Anthem, maybe it would have been deemed 'respectful' for Noreen to break out into the Hakka??? Sounds to me like Mrs Laidlaw is pushing someone else's barrow to me!! If it were that offensive to her and her fellow Women's Guild member's.........why didn't she contact the Media in April??? And for the record.......I wouldn't sing it either...especially as they failed to teach me the words in the Govt school I attended. Hey....let's blame Noreen for that too!!!!!!
    Posted by Flabbergasted, 1/07/2009 10:40:25 AM
    If what goes around comes around then those who choose to forget the past will be deservedly forgotten just as quickly. A bit of respect for those who risked (and lost) their lives for those of us yet to be born would be nice. Besides the Queen is still our Queen, and she needs God's help as much as the next bloke.
    Posted by Adrian, 1/07/2009 10:52:16 AM
    C'mon Mrs Laidlaw & the WWW Guild, "get over it". Is this really the most important issue you have to concern yourselves with? I'm not a supporter of Ms Hay's politics at all, but from her attendance record for the day it seems to me that she made a fine effort to show respect to all people who have served Australia in armed conflicts. My non-Anglo relatives who served Australia in WW1, WW2 & Korea ("definately" not out of any patriotic loyalty to the British Crown, a British anthem nor the Union Jack) would wholeheartedly agree.
    Posted by RAZ, 1/07/2009 11:00:37 AM
    Nah, I wouldn't sing GSTQ for the life of me. Being a born and bred Aussie, and coming from Scottish stock, then I have two reasons to never ever sing it. Our anthem is Advance Ozzy Fair, and next in line is Waltzing Matilda. Nothing to do with the queers, sorry queen! Although I did marry a pom, but she would never sing it either. Her choice!
    Posted by Mike Hunt, 1/07/2009 11:12:52 AM
    now we know why we should become a Republic what nonsence and I am 72 years of age so its not just an age thing
    Posted by JMcC, 1/07/2009 12:06:09 PM
    1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

    post a comment


    Screen name  *
    Email address  *
    Remember me?
    Comment  *
     
    We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
    Audrey Laidlaw, of Wollongong War Widows' Guild, is not happy with Noreen Hay. Picture: SYLVIA LIBER
    Audrey Laidlaw, of Wollongong War Widows' Guild, is not happy with Noreen Hay. Picture: SYLVIA LIBER
    Ms Hay is accused of being disrespectful.
    Ms Hay is accused of being disrespectful.
    Related Coverage
    POLL
    Q: Should Noreen Hay apologise for not singing God Save the Queen at an Anzac Day service?

    Yes
    (42.2%)

    No
    (57.8%)

    Total Votes: 490
    Poll Date: 30 June, 2009

    Most popular articles

     
    GPT GROUP WILL 14.3.10
     
     
    Lift your interest rate with an IMB Term Deposit
     
    Illawarra Mercury Drive
     SEND...
     SAVE...
     SHARE...