News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Push for noise-free trains 

Push for noise-free trains

07 Feb, 2012 08:45 AM
Train commuters travelling between Newcastle, the central coast and Sydney will soon be able to ride in ''quiet carriages'' where talking is discouraged.

The Minister for Transport, Gladys Berejiklian, will announce a trial of the initiative today. She says that, if successful, the quiet carriages could be extended to other long-distance commuter lines.

From Monday, the first and last carriages of all six- and eight-car trains on the Newcastle and central coast line will be quiet carriages. Only the last car of four-carriage trains will be designated a quiet zone.

As in other jurisdictions where the concept has been introduced, the carriages will be self-policed and will make use of signs and announcements to inform commuters of the low-noise policy.

The idea is that if someone is being too loud, the signs should embolden other commuters to ask them to be quiet.

"Many customers are telling us they want a noise-free environment on their train trip," Ms Berejiklian said.

"In a recent CityRail customer survey, 70 per cent of passengers said they found loud talking on trains annoying and 67 per cent found loud music disruptive."

Quiet carriages are already in use in Brisbane and on train lines in the United States and in Britain.

They have had mixed success in Brisbane: while some commuters appreciate the concept, others are frustrated by a lack of enforcement.

The MP for Gosford, Chris Holstein, said the government would seek feedback after the three-month trial.

"The success of this trial will rely on the goodwill of those in the quiet carriages and the respect they show their fellow passengers by keeping noise to a minimum," Mr Holstein said.

"The views of passengers will be sought on the effectiveness of the trial and what works and what doesn't."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
well they cant 'police' no drinking, no feet on seats, no smoking now. how will they be able to police not being quiet.

and maybe enforcing being quiet is going a little far.

just banning (loud, moronic, pointless) mobile conversations would be better and have much more support..

Posted by nick, 7/02/2012 9:21:23 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
What's needed are "mobile phone free carriages."

Nothing is more annoying than sitting on a train while some foul mouthed, uneducated person is having an open coversation on their mobile phone and every second word is is "F" this and "F" that.

Posted by Grumpyoldfart, 7/02/2012 9:28:25 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
If there were sufficient guards on the trains they could enforce a general good behaviour policy on all trains. Why should it be left to the poor commuter to "police" this? It's pathetic to try and enforce a "no talking policy". Instead of wasting money on "trials" such as this, use the money to get some decent guards back on the trains.
Posted by Helen, 7/02/2012 9:41:31 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Regarding the quiet carriages - I hope this will exclude passengers with IPods? Nothing is worse than sitting near someone with the constant thud and vibrating music.
Posted by Irene Tognetti, 7/02/2012 9:48:22 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Quiet trains eh?

Wow I thought NSW was going to get a very fast and VERY quiet train service like other countries!

Oops silly me.

Posted by jj, 7/02/2012 9:49:05 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Wont work. Its a nice idea but in reality its furphy. I have used the trains 6 days per week, twice a day for 30 years & have been involved in altercations with ill behaved people, thugs & ratbags on the train. The drug users, drunks, louts, ill behaved youth & assorted nutjobs are semingly allowed almost free reign to behave as they wish both on the trains & on the stations. Rail Police operating with a unrelenting zero tolerance attitude on CityRail property & on trains is what is needed.
Posted by Ray, 7/02/2012 10:32:26 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
What a heap of garbage. Why not have trains with no pasenger and all the problems will no longer be a problem.
Posted by john of figtree, 7/02/2012 10:51:40 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Works in Japan, as they have a different (better) attitude towards society and public property. Will not work here, unless policed by other travellers... and that could end badly.
Posted by Ang, 7/02/2012 10:57:03 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
Ang,

Are you kidding? You have no idea! Japan a better attitude towards society!!!! Crap!

I suppose that is why Japan rail commuters have problems with groping on trains. Touching up etc of females on overcrowded trains. This is a regular occurrence. That is why women grab the hands of these males, raise the hands in the air and publicly humiliate these males!

Posted by Correction required, 7/02/2012 11:50:32 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
I agree with Ang, used the train system in Japan extensively and I loved it. As said though the people in Japan do have a better attitude and respect each other. I don't need to hear your life story on the train as you shout down your mobile telephone.
Posted by Jabz, 7/02/2012 12:05:48 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Photo: GREG TOTMAN
Photo: GREG TOTMAN
Related Coverage
POLL
Q: Do we need "quiet carriages" on trains?

Yes
(80.1%)

No
(19.9%)

Total Votes: 577
Poll Date: 07 February, 2012

Most popular articles




Illawarra Mercury







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...