Why is our health service $65m in the red?

By Angela Thompson and Aap
Updated November 5 2012 - 11:45pm, first published December 16 2009 - 9:52am
Why is our health service $65m in the red?
Why is our health service $65m in the red?

The region's health service has blown its budget by more than $23 million, ending the last financial year almost $65 million in the red.And little of the massive spending went towards the upkeep of medical equipment, with maintenance spending less than half what it should be. The latest indictment of South Eastern Sydney Illawarra Area Health's balance sheet is contained in a financial audit by Auditor-General Peter Achterstraat.

  • EDITORIAL: Prognosis still grim for the health service
  • Exposed: attempts to silence Illawarra doctorIt shows the service's problems paying bills on time are ongoing and that the area has the fewest vacant hospital beds in NSW.The health service ended the financial year with a $64.8 million deficit - $23.3 million worse than the budgeted deficit of $41.5 million. In his report, Mr Achterstraat noted health service advice that the shortfall was due to capital works projects being deferred, resulting in less revenue from government grants.A $5.5 million Federal Government bail-out helped reduce total creditors to $60.7 million, down from $84.8 million. However about $18 million of the debt was more than two months old.And some of the $20 million debt classed as "on hold or in dispute" could have been deliberately delayed by invalid purchase orders."We have reported this for the last two years, and recommended that purchases need to be accompanied by valid orders," the report read."The lack of action on this issue could give the impression, perhaps mistakenly, that this is being used as a means of deferring payments to suppliers."Opposition health spokeswoman Jillian Skinner backed the Auditor-General's suggestion."I've had creditors tell me that's exactly what's happening - that they have had goods ordered, then, when they've gone to get money from the invoices, the hospital says, 'oh no, we haven't got a record of that'," Mrs Skinner said. "Then they go through this whole process of months of delay."Mrs Skinner said the health service's actual debts were worse than the report showed because overdue wages weren't included, and because "the area health services have always had this trick of paying off bills by June 30 and then letting them pile up again".She condemned the region's lowly spending on maintenance - 0.8 per cent of gross asset values, less than half the benchmark 2 per cent and below the 1.1 per cent state average."It means that the buildings and the equipment are not up to scratch and, in the end, the repair bills end up greater than the cost of maintaining them," she said.Within South Eastern Sydney Illawarra bed occupancy increased by 2.4 per cent to 93.3 per cent - the highest in NSW and well above the "safe" benchmark (85 per cent) or the state average (87.4 per cent).Statewide, the report found many services still have trouble paying creditors on time. Only two of the eight health services paid creditors within the 45-day target last financial year, despite promises from former health minister John Della Bosca he would fix the problem. The audit also found emergency departments were failing to meet some treatment benchmarks, hospital waiting lists had blown out from 58,173 people to 64,512, while only one service had done a proper stocktake of its equipment. Complaints to the Health Care Complaints Commission rose 23.4 per cent, while more than $500 million in equipment was past its use-by date.
  • Subscribe now for unlimited access.

    $0/

    (min cost $0)

    or signup to continue reading

    See subscription options

    Get the latest Wollongong news in your inbox

    Sign up for our newsletter to stay up to date.

    We care about the protection of your data. Read our Privacy Policy.