News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Woonona shops 'facing $6mil loss' 

Woonona shops 'facing $6mil loss'

24 Aug, 2009 05:00 AM
Up to $6 million would be sucked out of the Woonona economy, leaving small businesses to suffer, if a proposed supermarket was built in Bulli, according to the Woonona Chamber of Commerce.

Chamber president Graham Sturgiss said he was worried the development application lodged for a Woolworths at Bulli was dismissive of the impact on Woonona businesses.

"That was a little disappointing," Mr Sturgiss said.

  • Aldi joins Woolies in northern suburbs

    "It (suggested) they could take $6 million out of the Woonona shopping centre and it would have no impact. I think we will suffer."

    The DA proposed a Woolworths be built on the corner of Molloy St and the Princes Hwy.

    Plans for an Aldi supermarket in Woonona also have been unveiled in recent weeks, potentially adding further pressure to established businesses.

    The Woolworths DA said the proposed supermarket would have the greatest impact on Woonona stores, redirecting business worth up to $6 million during its first year of operation.

    In a submission to Wollongong City Council opposing the DA, the chamber noted the loss of business would lead to job cuts, a reduction in customers visiting Woonona shops and the gradual decline of the village shopping centre.

    "To highlight our case, we have contacted Franklins Woonona and have confirmed that the average spend per customer is $30," the submission said.

    "If the assumptions are correct ... this would relate a loss of 200,000 customers per year from our shopping centre."

    Mr Sturgiss said the chamber could not see a business case for the Woolworths being built.

    "You don't see long queues at Franklins Woonona and Coles Corrimal," he said.

    "Establishing another supermarket would be transferring business from one to another."

    Traffic congestion and heritage controls were also raised in the chamber's submission.

  • Mr Stugiss said if the Woolworths went ahead, there would be more traffic congestion at Bulli with the addition of two sets of traffic lights once the Northern Distributor extension opened.

    The submission noted that heritage controls in Bulli, which other businesses had adhered to, did not seem to apply to the proposed Woolworths.

    "Given that this development is in close proximity to the Bulli Conservation Area, there has been no consideration for the design to be sympathetic to the existing streetscape."

    The exhibition period for the DA closed last Friday, by which time the council had received seven submissions - one in favour and six against.

    Print
    Increase Text Size
    Decrease Text Size

    comments


    Date: Newest first | Oldest first
    The 'shops' at Woonona are terrible any way, I wouldn't shop there in a million years. Crusty old buildings with overpriced poor quality products. Go Woolworths! Will be great not to have to drive to Corrimal.
    Posted by Shopper, 24/08/2009 7:55:56 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
    When it was known BiLo was coming to Helensburgh, some shop keepers were anxious, and the small dilapidated IGA store really kicked up a fuss.

    BiLo came, IGA went (really no sad loss as staff found a job at BiLo) and no resident had to run off to Engadine, some 16km away to shop.

    Businesses actually kept going, and in some cases did better because of the increased traffic flow, with residents, used to shopping at big supermarkets, now staying.

    The flip side was that some businesses were looking forward to BiLo coming in, as they thought there be an increase in people traffic. Time has proven them right.

    Posted by Observer, 24/08/2009 8:16:09 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
    Everything Mr Sturgiss has said is spot on. Woolworths & Aldi will be the death of Woonona businesses. Now lets see if WCC have the courage to stand up to the big retailers & knock back these 2 absolutely unnecessary developments.
    Posted by RAS, 24/08/2009 8:35:49 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
    I wish we still had local stores in Wollongong.
    Posted by Fish, 24/08/2009 8:56:37 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
    There will be winners and losers in this venture..Residents of he Northern Suburbs deserve a supermarket. Those who now go to Corrimal and Fairymeadow to shop will most likely shop in the new stores closer to home,thus saving petrol. All they need now is a shuttle bus Oh, sorry, I forgot , it's not Wollongong
    Posted by Annie, 24/08/2009 11:36:32 AM, on Illawarra Mercury
    I wish I had time to go to 5 or 8 shops instead of 1, including time to make corresponding number of individual payments.
    Posted by Barry, 24/08/2009 12:07:31 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    its not that a supermarket(s) in the northern suburbs is not a good idea, its just that where they have been proposed is/are not a good place!
    Posted by Shaun Prince, 24/08/2009 12:14:11 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    As a few have said already there is good & bad with these scenerios. The fact is that Franklins does not cater well enough for the area, they LACK grocery lines and are poorly staffed hence why us northerners reluctantly have to travel to corrimal and beyond. They should shut down franklins replace it with woolies or aldi and just maybe other decent shopkeepers will fill all the empty shops but please no more crap eateries, we deserve so much better and if no improvements are made to the dismal looking shops already there this will become a ghost town.
    Posted by shopper2, 24/08/2009 3:38:13 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    Observer, the increased traffic might have been better for some Helensburgh businesses, but these proposals are for well outside the Woonona shopping strip. This means people won't be going to Woonona - they'll go instead to the new shopping mall/arcade/franchisee hell-hole instead. It's a move away from the publicly-owned high street, and towards a privately-owned and operated space, with all the control that implies, over what you can do there. Street-accessed, people-friendly shopping is much better for people's well-being, sense of community and resulting trust and social capital.
    Posted by Jill, 26/08/2009 6:03:47 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    We have managed without Woolies for all this time and remember that they want to be here to make money not to serve us.

    Their D A shows contempt for the locals by having their main entrance from the main road with yet another set of traffic lights and restrictions on traffic into Organs road.That will be three sets of traffic lights and an offset roundabout between Hospital road and Park road Bulli.

    Imagine the increased congestion as overflow parking from Woolies combines with funeral traffic from the two local funeral homes and a busy Police Boys club.

    If we must have Woolies then they should revise their plans, change their footprint,and make use of the Molloy street and Station street frontages and in doing so create more in-house parking than the one space presently allocated above Council's minimum.

    With a bit more research they could increase their parking spaces,save the cost of a set of traffic lights and reduce the congestion on our main highway without reducing the size of their footprint.We should not forget that future Woolies plans involve a petrol station adjacent to the proposed entrance road thus adding to the already congested Princes Highway. Woolies just GO AWAY!!!!

    Posted by Ron, 13/09/2009 9:43:13 PM, on Illawarra Mercury
    1 | 2  |  next >

    post a comment


    Screen name  *
    Email address  *
    Remember me?
    Comment  *
     
    We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
    Mr Sturgiss
    Mr Sturgiss
    Related Coverage
    ARTICLES

    Most popular articles


    Cool Blue Air Conditioning Pty Ltd
     


    Illawarra Mercury







    Weather brought to you by:

    Weatherzone

    Classifieds

    Front Page

    Current Issue
    Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
     SEND...
     SAVE...
     SHARE...