News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Carbon scheme jeopardises Port Kembla steelworks: BlueScope 

Carbon scheme jeopardises Port Kembla steelworks: BlueScope

02 Apr, 2009 11:29 AM
A catastrophic economic downturn awaits the Illawarra if the Federal Government ploughs ahead with its emissions trading scheme, BlueScope Steel has warned.

Chief executive Noel Cornish said yesterday the viability of the Port Kembla steelworks - along with the 12,000 jobs it supports - would be under threat if the Government's Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme (CPRS) took effect in its present form.

  • Read chief executive Noel Cornish's statement to the committee [pdf]

    Speaking before a Senate select committee in Wollongong, which is investigating the impact of the emissions trading scheme, Mr Cornish painted a nightmare portrait in which Australian steel could become uncompetitive and business moved offshore.

    "If our business becomes unviable in the global marketplace then the whole Port Kembla steelworks is threatened," he said.

    Mr Cornish's comments represent BlueScope's bluntest assessment yet of the impact of the Government's emissions trading scheme.

    He said "tens of millions" of dollars would be wiped from the company's books in the first year if the plan came into effect.

    "Costs of this magnitude would be difficult to bear in good economic times - in the current downturn they would be disastrous," Mr Cornish said.

    "There is a real danger that an aggressive CPRS, particularly one that results in Australia acting ahead of major (international) competitors, could compound current financial difficulties and affect the ongoing viability of the Australian iron and steel industry."

    He said steel production had plummeted 50 per cent since October last year due to the global economic crisis, placing pressure on jobs and finances.

    "We are basically working ... to make sure we get through this crisis and I don't think we have any capacity to take on a tax that does not apply to our competitors."

    Sitting next to Mr Cornish was BlueScope general manager Alan Thomas who said the scheme could drive steel production into the hands of the world's biggest polluters, China and India.

  • "In July 2010 we will be the only steel industry we are aware of on the Earth that will have those imposts," he said.

    After the committee's hearing, Australian Workers Union branch secretary Andy Gillespie played down fears and said the unions had been in intensive discussions with the Government about the scheme.

    "I think it is a bit premature for BlueScope to say all this when there has been no firm decision at this point in time," he said.

    "The union has been locked in heavy discussions with the Federal Government with the assistance of our local members ... those discussions are not finalised and are ongoing.

    "(BlueScope) should just wait and see what is going to happen instead of putting the fear of Christ into the workforce."

    The Senate committee also heard from Futureworld board member Stephen Gale, who said the Government should not delay the implementation of an emissions trading scheme because of the global downturn.

    "I don't think that the overall timelines should be changed," he said. "The overall threat from climate change is not going to slow down because we are in a recession."

    Print
    Increase Text Size
    Decrease Text Size

    comments


    Date: Newest first | Oldest first
    At the moment it seems BlueScope steel is more interested in protecting its own sheltered position than putting effort into solving real problems. For how long have they known that global warming is going to have to be paid for by future generations? It would be hard to think that a technical focussed company like BlueScope is in denial regarding the weight of scientific evidence available on climate change. So do they regard themselves as part of the problem and if so why can't they divert energies into finding solutions rather than moaning that they are not getting enough protection.
    Posted by markz, 2/04/2009 8:46:15 AM
    I agree with markz. Bluescope Steel have not publicised any alternative solution to a carbon emissions trading scheme. They are saying that they want a level playing field with China. Heaven help this world if everyone uses that argument and sits on their hands waiting for China to be the ones to lead. The air in China is so polluted its unbreathable. Is that the future we want for our kids and grandkids?
    Posted by Cathy B of Figtree, 2/04/2009 1:07:24 PM
    The importance of protecting jobs and sustaining manufacturing industry in Australia is paramount. Is it worth putting people out of a job and destroying business? Maybe Mark would hold a different view if it were his job at risk or he couldn't put food on his tobale to feed his family.
    Posted by amanda, 2/04/2009 2:01:04 PM
    The way I see, if BlueScope dont show initiative and foresight to implement a competitive business model for the future, then they deserve to go out of business. The same with GM and Chrysler, these two companies are uncompetitive in todays environment. If a business is uncompetitive then it should be allowed to go into insolvency in order for stronger companies that have competitive business models to succeed and build a better world. The government would be morally wrong to modify the emissions trading scheme so that businesses such as BlueScope who are no longer viable can stay in business for the benefit of 12,000 jobs. Lets not forget the bigger picture, one company in the scheme of things does not even compare to the long term sustainability of our environment.
    Posted by Reader, 2/04/2009 4:15:58 PM
    Climate change quacks. There is a growing body of evidence repudiating many of the key assumptions (which is all they are) regarding climate change. Climate change is a trendy cause the likes of Al Gore and Ross Garnaut have championed to further their own names, at the expense of the economies of countries like Australia. Until the proof of climate change is 100% undeniable- which many are starting to think will never happen- then it is unbecoming of the champagne socialists with no idea, to preach to the entire country their paternalistic "we know best" social engineering agenda.
    Posted by Kristan, 2/04/2009 4:42:18 PM
    In my opinion Bluescope steel is currently run by managers that are only concerned with surrounding themselves with company yes men to pat each other on the back and shut their eyes to real issues that concern the community. Bring back George Edgar. He genuinely cared.
    Posted by steph, 2/04/2009 11:23:36 PM
    I find it absolutely jaw dropping that some people think its OK to wipe at least 4700 well paying jobs off the face of the earth so that Australia gets a good editorial in some environmental groups monthly newsletter next to ads for solar dunnies! Wake up Australians, you're being sold a load of you know what by the same cranks that buy products from countries with little or no environmental regulation. Had a look at a Chinese steel plants emissions lately?
    Posted by Broph, 3/04/2009 2:02:42 AM
    This is obviously a huge issue for the Illawarra. There are far more than 4,700 jobs at stake - the steelworks is unquestionably the key economic driver for this region. Taking an environmental stand that puts Australian businesses at a major international disadvantage is completely bonkers. The way I understand it, the carbon scheme does not actually reduce pollution - it just imposes a charge for it. Higher polluters pay more, lower polluters pay less.
    Posted by BJ, 3/04/2009 11:33:23 AM
    If Australian products are less competitive in the international marketplace due to our people wanting a greener environment and a nicer place to live on the future then the government should put high import taxes on products that are from countries that don't support the higher and more costly greener production methods.
    Posted by Beth, 11/04/2009 11:17:36 PM
    Wake up Australia! Lose this steelworks and it is all downhill from there. We will just be the pit and the farm, because we are too stupid to value add beyond that. Thanks to the Federal Government (IT migration) the Australian IT Industry in which I have spent 24 years is stuffed, and now they are gunning for our state of the art Steel Industry. We need University Degrees in aged care, because that is all that will be left to do.
    Posted by casemate, 19/05/2009 10:10:00 AM

    post a comment


    Screen name  *
    Email address  *
    Remember me?
    Comment  *
     
    We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
    BlueScope general manager Alan Thomas says China and India are set  to pounce. Picture: ROBERT PEET
    BlueScope general manager Alan Thomas says China and India are set to pounce. Picture: ROBERT PEET

    Most popular articles


    Cool Blue Air Conditioning Pty Ltd
     


    Illawarra Mercury







    Weather brought to you by:

    Weatherzone

    Classifieds

    Front Page

    Current Issue
    Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
     SEND...
     SAVE...
     SHARE...