News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Sumo the Alaskan malamute not a danger: owner 

Sumo the Alaskan malamute not a danger: owner

12 Sep, 2008 05:00 AM
Sumo the Alaskan malamute attacked and killed a free-range chook but his owner does not believe it makes him a danger to the community.

Figtree's Walter Duran is set to fight for his dog's reputation by appealing a Wollongong City Council decision to categorise him a dangerous dog.

"He did wrong but it wasn't serious enough to put him in a muzzle - that would kill him," Mr Duran said.

He pleaded guilty in Wollongong Local Court yesterday to being an owner of a dog which attacked another animal.

It was alleged Sumo on April 24 this year got out of his yard and attacked and killed a chicken in the yard in Mary Ave, Figtree.

The chicken owner restrained the dog to a tree until Mr Duran arrived, the court heard.

Since the attack, Sumo has been declared a dangerous dog, which imposes a number of conditions on ownership, including the need to muzzle the dog in public and house the dog in a metal enclosure in the back yard.

Magistrate Paul Johnson fined Mr Duran $100 considerably less than the $550 local government fine.

Mr Duran was happy with the result but still wants to appeal the dangerous dog classification.

"I admitted in court that Sumo did the deed, but he has never touched a human and gets on great with kids," Mr Duran said.

"I think the classification is an over-reaction.

"When I found Sumo after the attack he was tied to a tree looking very forlorn like a naughty child.

"But he's a dog and nine out of 10 dogs would munch a chicken," he said.

The court heard Sumo had a record of wandering over the past five years, with four incidents.

"Whenever he gets out it has been my mistake, but he is a beautiful dog and most people love him," Mr Duran said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I think that the punishment is a bit harsh for poor Sumo.

Alaskan Malamutes are not known for a vicious nature but more of a friendly family dog.

I'm sorry for the chicken, but I think Sumo probably thought it as a playmate more than anything but obviously overdid it.

I say just be thankful it wasn't human otherwise poor Sumo would have to be put to sleep and that would be devasting for Mr Duran.

I wish Mr Duran the best of luck to him and Sumo, I agree with him that the outcome is a little harsh. Perhaps give them a second chance to prove themselves?

Posted by Tamara, 12/09/2008 10:21:43 AM
Dangerous dog kills chicken! How ridiculous! Most dogs would attack a chicken. A fully grown cat could and probably would also attack a chicken.

This is making the law look silly.

Posted by Fergie, 12/09/2008 1:49:31 PM
I find it hard to beleive that if Sumo was so vicious how did the owner of the chicken manage to tie him to a tree?

What's the world coming to?

Its intrinsic in all animals to go for smaller prey....Considering Malamutes are know for their affection to human kind, I don't know that I'd call him a dangerous dog.

Good Luck Mr Duran.

Posted by zac, 12/09/2008 3:01:42 PM
Isn't Sumo only acting on his animal instincts? Any dog regardless of breed would go after a chook. My normally harmless and friendly staffie caught and killed an Indian myna bird yesterday. The difference? No one say Jack being a normal dog. Is he a danger to the public? No way! Another case of bureaucracy gone mad!... Good luck Sumo and Mr Duran. .
Posted by Roxy, 12/09/2008 6:11:44 PM
I think he's lucky the punishment is not more severe. It's not just the chicken - why was the dog on public land (and then other private property) unsupervised? And it's happened four times before. I wouldn't want to be walking with my small children anywhere near that property - they always say "he never bites people" and then they do.
Posted by Chris, 12/09/2008 7:29:36 PM
Any domestic dog that kills chickens is a domestic dog that will do it again. This dog given similar circumstances would most likely do the same thing. Coming home and finding your chickens killed because of a 'lovely dog who wouldn't hurt a fly' is most distressing. Chook killers are chook killers.
Posted by oldchook, 13/09/2008 8:35:22 AM
Sumo is no different to other dogs just because he is large. We had a malamute for 14 years and was the most gentle loving dog you could ever have. Sumo should have the right to walk down the street without a muzzle on with Mr Duran. I say to them both, hold your head up with pride, you both have the right to. Sumo, you did what any other dog would have done. I do feel sorry for the chicken but I don't believe you did it on purpose.
Posted by Sumo the Alaskan malamute not a danger: owner, 13/09/2008 1:33:31 PM
Of the five comments on this article, four were sympathetic to Sumo, and only one negative, while articles about humans attracted 0, 1, 2 comments. Perhaps this enforces the adage 'never work with children or animals'.
Posted by Fergie, 14/09/2008 10:41:08 AM
I am an alaskan malamute owner and have bred these dogs. They are the most wonderful dogs I have ever had. Gentle, loving, excellent with children, including my 1 year old grandson, in fact almost of a protective nature to him. How anyone could classify this dog as dangerous is a either a fool or just doesn't know this breed. If the owner reads this I want him too know that Sumo is beautiful and good luck getting this very stupid classification removed!!!!
Posted by LARRY, 27/09/2008 8:18:43 AM
Typical Council... blinkered, subjective and full of red tape. Nice dog. The sooner we get rid of Councils the better. Two levels of government is enough!
Posted by Nicko, 13/11/2008 4:48:18 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Walter Duran, owner of Alaskan malamute Sumo, says his beloved pet is not a dangerous dog. Picture: SYLVIA LIBER
Walter Duran, owner of Alaskan malamute Sumo, says his beloved pet is not a dangerous dog. Picture: SYLVIA LIBER

Most popular articles

 
 
Lift your interest rate with an IMB Term Deposit
 
Illawarra Mercury Drive
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...